A Generous Orthodoxy is one of the two free books I received from Zondervan just before Christmas. They invited me to post something on my blog about them, and it seemed a reasonable request. A second post will follow once I read the second book.

Having just finished AGO, I thoroughly enjoyed it. As promised it was in places “provocative, mischievous and unclear;” but in no way did I find it offensive or heretical. Perhaps this is because I’ve been in and around the emergent conversation for a little while now. My judgment may be skewed; so be it.

I most enjoyed McLaren’s tone. As I have found in other books by him, he is honest and sincere in his faith and his pursuit of God. There is no arrogance or haughtiness. Rather, I find humility and gentleness. He seems to be a man with a fair grasp on a wide variety of topics - history, theology, philosophy, etc. - and the rare ability to interweave these threads and express the tapestry he sees. When I read his works I find a man willing to ask difficult questions whether or not answers are available. I have always appreciated McLaren’s writing, and AGO deepens my appreciation.

My recommendations: If you one who feels called to stand firm and defend the traditional values, theologies, etc. of the faith, then I would urge you to consider avoiding the book. At best it will pull the rug out from under your feet; at worse it will infuriate you. You take your chances by reading. If, however, you are one who feels called to explore, shape and direct the leading edge of history, then I would unwaveringly recommend AGO. I think that your soul, like mine, will resonate with the chords McLaren strikes. Some tones are harmonious; others are countermelodies; but all enrich the song.

Links

A Generous Orthodoxy: the Blog